A list of the top 100 businesses that benefitted from the ChooseCBR voucher scheme has been released by the ACT Government, but the list has raised some questions about how businesses could claim such a large number of vouchers in the 25-hours the scheme ran.
Food retailers were the greatest beneficiaries. Almost 40 per cent of the vouchers were claimed at stores like grocers, while more than one in four were redeemed at cafes, restaurants and takeaway shops.
Daily Market City & Gungahlin topped the list, receiving 3.3 per cent of all vouchers redeemed.
Business Minister Tara Cheyne defended the scheme, saying the vouchers resulted in more than $5.1 million being spent at businesses across Canberra.
“These numbers show extraordinary demand from consumers and are testament to the enthusiasm of local businesses who embraced the scheme, marketed it, and encouraged old and new customers to come in and spend, and to spend more,” she said.
Ms Cheyne previously said the government would not release the list as she said the information was commercial in confidence.
Government figures revealed that 19 businesses redeemed more than 500 vouchers and 133 businesses redeemed more than 100 vouchers before the $2 million scheme ended.
To redeem 500 vouchers, a business would have had to redeem one voucher every three minutes for the entire 25 hours the scheme ran since it restarted at 7:00 am last Friday (18 June).
With voucher values ranging between $10 to $50, businesses that claimed above 500 vouchers would have made between $5000 and $25,000 from the vouchers alone.
Shadow Business Minister Leanne Castley has urged a review by the Auditor-General.
“Concerns remain about the speed in which vouchers were redeemed, which is one of the reasons we need an independent review by the Auditor-General,” Ms Castley said.
“The Auditor-General must scrutinise the entire scheme; in particular, transactions that took place over a 25-hour period.”
Neither the Legislative Assembly nor MLAs can instruct the Auditor-General to commence an inquiry, although parties can make a referral.
Ms Cheyne said a comprehensive review is already being conducted. She has written to the Auditor-General advising the office about the scheme’s review and that the findings of the review would be presented to the Auditor-General.
Earlier this week, Ms Cheyne said she had heard anecdotal evidence that businesses were manually redeeming vouchers late into the night, including vouchers submitted online, which explains why some vouchers were processed between midnight and 6:00 am.
Ms Cheyne said there had been no reports of the scheme being misused but conceded that it might not be possible for the review to determine whether some customers had exploited the scheme by signing up twice.
An analysis of the scheme’s trial found a questionable pattern of inexplicable transactions across three businesses worth $5355.
The government did not seek to recover the money as it would have cost more than the transactions were worth, Ms Cheyne said, although the three businesses were banned from participating in the scheme’s full rollout.
Almost 800 businesses took part in the voucher scheme, 180 of which received less than $50 from the scheme.
One in five Canberra businesses that were eligible under the guidelines participated in the scheme.
The top 100 businesses were:
- Daily Market City & Gungahlin
- Hualong Supermarket
- Chemist Warehouse Belconnen Markets
- Deji Asian Supermarket
- Oriental Groceries
- Panda Fresh Mart
- Mega Convenience Store
- Mani Asian Supermarket
- Wukong Hotpot & Super Emoji
- Bestore Asian Supermarket
- Sai Gon Asian Grocery
- Fresco Seafood
- Sycamore Medi Spa
- Ebest Canberra
- Asian Supa Grocery
- Easi Mart Kingston
- Z Cosme Store
- Yum Cha CBD
- Vina Groceries
- Ginger and Spice
- Chilada & VR Canberra
- Emart Asian Supermarket
- Desi Bazzar
- Tak Kee Roast Inn
- The Food Forum
- Oscar’s Bakery Cafe
- Yesmart
- Gungahlin & Jamison Plaza Travel Associates
- Raku Dining
- Lost River Produce
- Gungahlin Lakes Golf Pro Shop
- Pandora Belconnen and Pandora Canberra Centre
- MK Butcher
- Weston Asian Grocery
- Nikki Cosmo
- Toyworld Fyshwick & Toyworld Belconnen
- Super Emoji Citywalk
- Dymocks Canberra
- Cool Buy
- Jimmy’s Place
- Hing Shing Butcher
- 606 Asian Supermarket
- ACT Fruit Veg and Butcher
- National Zoo & Aquarium
- The Golden Drum
- Deakin IGA
- Ai Buy Market
- UC Supermarket
- Dendy Cinemas Canberra Centre
- Rashays Belconnen
- The Scholar Chinese Seafood Restaurant
- Bellchambers Music School
- Little Sprout
- Chinese Inn Restaurant
- Rusden Europro Automotive
- Dymocks Belconnen
- Tasty Fish Market
- Mont Adventure Equipment
- Guzman y Gomez Canberra Centre, Belconnen & Gunghalin
- Here Collective
- Impact Comics
- Capital Chemist Dickson
- Continental Grocery & Halal Meat
- Bidgee Golf Shop
- Super Emoji Gungahlin
- TG-ONE Groceries Coffee
- Ziggys Fresh Belconnen
- PappaRich Canberra
- Asian Provisions
- IGA Drakeford
- Fortune Box
- Tackle World Canberra
- Bread & Butter Café
- POP Canberra
- Kippax Asian Grocer
- Across The Board Cake Decorating Pty Ltd
- Pandora Tuggeranong
- O2 Hair
- Chic Gourmet
- Tasting China
- Smart Dollar Tuggeranong
- Star Buffet
- Let’s Be Natural
- Pharmacy Select Gungahlin
- Latorta
- Landspeed Records
- Canberra City Gymnastics Club
- Daily Market Kambri
- Discount Grocery Store Phillip
- Sichuan Chinese Restaurant
- Pedal Power ACT
- artKids Canberra
- Crafty Frog
- Bellelis
- Limelight Cinemas
- Capital Chemist Lyneham
- Rashays Tuggeranong
- Akikambara
- Belconnen Chicken
- Hey Show Karaoke.
Original Article published by Dominic Giannini on The RiotACT.